Welcome to the Laid Back Boaters message board When you register, be sure to check the proper box for your age!
As a guest, you will not be able to see all the content of this message board. After registering you will have access to all forums, post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple, and absolutely free, so please, join our community today!
Joined: May 7th, 2009, 10:54 am Posts: 1116 Location: North Highlands, CA
Well do to my almost "Chuck Norris" like ability to visualy analyze mechanical devices! I think I have found a difference between an Exit housing that "Cavitates when Hit hard out of the Hole, and one that "Does Not" In an "Axial Flow style Pump, what should the distance from impeller vanes to the stator vanes be? The reason I ask is.....the stator vanes are 3MM farther away from the impeller on the exit housing that cavitates. here's the comparison.
What you guys think, that difference cause it to Cav?
_________________ aka: Steve Mac 78- 21' Tahiti Super Cruiser- 460 w/ Panther Jet
Joined: March 15th, 2009, 11:29 am Posts: 194 Location: Eastern Kansas
Did you guys hear that Chuck Norris jumped into a pool and didn't get wet.... the water got Chuck Norrised
Now on to more serious matters. I would think that if you make a gasket that was an additional 3mm and put it on the non-cavitaing exit housing and try it that would tell you if the 3mm is the difference or if something else is your culprit. If for some reason that fixes it you can take 3mm off the mounting face of the cavitating one.
_________________ ...that's why we don't have nice things...
Joined: May 7th, 2009, 10:54 am Posts: 1116 Location: North Highlands, CA
I've heard that "Cats have Chuck Norris like reflexes!"
74konaproject wrote:
If for some reason that fixes it you can take 3mm off the mounting face of the cavitating one.
Except I dont have a mill, and it is more than one surface, outside flange, outside lip, stator face, stator ring height, DU bushing and seal Height. I was thinking of tig welding a bead on the stator vanes, and reprofile the leading edge!
_________________ aka: Steve Mac 78- 21' Tahiti Super Cruiser- 460 w/ Panther Jet
Joined: May 7th, 2009, 10:54 am Posts: 1116 Location: North Highlands, CA
In the first part of this video, you can hear me pedal the throttle a bit to try and limit the RPM's. You hear the amount of slip I'm getting. Very Annoying.
_________________ aka: Steve Mac 78- 21' Tahiti Super Cruiser- 460 w/ Panther Jet
Joined: September 6th, 2008, 6:21 pm Posts: 2612 Location: NorCal
78_Tahiti wrote:
Well do to my almost "Chuck Norris" like ability to visualy analyze mechanical devices! I think I have found a difference between an Exit housing that "Cavitates when Hit hard out of the Hole, and one that "Does Not" In an "Axial Flow style Pump, what should the distance from impeller vanes to the stator vanes be? The reason I ask is.....the stator vanes are 3MM farther away from the impeller on the exit housing that cavitates. here's the comparison.
What you guys think, that difference cause it to Cav?
very interesting! I agree with kona on the gasket thing would give you and answer.....thinking as I type and in doing so, it may not give the proper answer. The reason being is putting a thick gasket in there will move the stator ring further back also which can and probably will cause the efficiency to go down. Hmmmmm
Joined: May 7th, 2009, 10:54 am Posts: 1116 Location: North Highlands, CA
Cas wrote:
The reason being is putting a thick gasket in there will move the stator ring further back also which can and probably will cause the efficiency to go down. Hmmmmm
My thoughts exactly. For the Helluvit, I sent Steve@Panther Jet an email, mentioning that I had aquired another Panther Jet. and see what the spec is between impeller edge and stator blade. we'll see if he answers
_________________ aka: Steve Mac 78- 21' Tahiti Super Cruiser- 460 w/ Panther Jet
Joined: May 7th, 2009, 10:54 am Posts: 1116 Location: North Highlands, CA
Oh yeah, since I had the tail off anyways, I tapped all of the vent holes in the stator vanes to be able to plug them easily to see what that does. I even picked up 8 set ss screws to do it.
_________________ aka: Steve Mac 78- 21' Tahiti Super Cruiser- 460 w/ Panther Jet
Joined: September 6th, 2008, 6:21 pm Posts: 2612 Location: NorCal
78_Tahiti wrote:
Oh yeah, since I had the tail off anyways, I tapped all of the vent holes in the stator vanes to be able to plug them easily to see what that does. I even picked up 8 set ss screws to do it.
damn, lots of holes! Why don't you just leave the top 4 holes unplugged so when you run down the river you'll look like a peacock
Joined: October 10th, 2008, 9:00 pm Posts: 50 Location: Sebastopol Ca.
Steve, How are you...... I would slow down a bit before you start blocking off those vent holes, they are there for a reason. The stator seal mates with the rear face of the impeller to relieve the pressure on the rear of the impeller and reduce the thrust load on the shaft tail bearings. Leakage in this area is vented by these holes. A tight fit should be maintained between the impeller and stator seal. This is controlled by shimming washers ahead of the impeller. This is the axial clearance, it should be .020 to .030. To check the axial clearance you lay a straight edge across the rear face of the pump housing with the impeller on the shaft and measure the gap with a feeler gauge. The radial clearance is the distance between the ridges of the stator seal and the inside of the impeller hub. This should be .015. If your stator seal ridges are worn you will loose alot of efficiency here. Hole shot cavitation won't come from the vent holes. You have other issues. Jim
Joined: May 7th, 2009, 10:54 am Posts: 1116 Location: North Highlands, CA
Thanks Jim for posting. I was hoping you and/or Tom would jump in. with a straight edge, impeller clearance is .020", the stator rings are even in better shape on the tail housing with the Panthervator then in my exit housing. yet I see no cavitation with my exit installed. The only 2 physical differences I could find were the distance to the stator blades from the impeller & the size of the exit. This is a sleeved pump and all the other pump specs are well within the numbers. just trying to figure out where the variable is between the 2 exits thats causing the cavitation.
_________________ aka: Steve Mac 78- 21' Tahiti Super Cruiser- 460 w/ Panther Jet
Joined: September 11th, 2008, 12:49 am Posts: 875 Location: SF Bay Area CA.
78_Tahiti wrote:
Thanks Jim for posting. I was hoping you and/or Tom would jump in. with a straight edge, impeller clearance is .020", the stator rings are even in better shape on the tail housing with the Panthervator then in my exit housing. yet I see no cavitation with my exit installed. The only 2 physical differences I could find were the distance to the stator blades from the impeller & the size of the exit. This is a sleeved pump and all the other pump specs are well within the numbers. just trying to figure out where the variable is between the 2 exits thats causing the cavitation.
I read a little further back that you also use a gasket between the 2 housings?? I can say I only feel cavatation at high speed with rough water but mine does not have a gasket I use black silicone sealer between the 2 housings plus I have the 4" FINS on the trim plate. I do know not having the gasket will make the impeller closer to the stator housing and the fins help the handleing these are the only changes that have been done to mine.
_________________ "No offense" means "I'm about to insult you,but don't get mad."
Joined: May 7th, 2009, 10:54 am Posts: 1116 Location: North Highlands, CA
Kriss, I DO NOT have a gasket between the pump and rear housing. That was a possible suggestion to see if my original exit would cavitate like the Panthervator one does. I have the 2" deep fins on my ride plate, which I like better then the smooth one I had before. I went ahead and welded a piece of 1/8" Stainless on each side of my Panthervator nozzle to make the exit size the same as my original. (which does NOT cavitate) so next time out I'll see if that makes any difference. If not, the only other difference between the 2 exit housings is the distance from the back of the impeller to the stator vanes. So after next test I may weld a couple of beads on to each vane, reprofile them and see if thats possibly where the problem is. From what I've read, and everyone I have talked to, no one seems to think that the difference in the stator vanes would cause cavitation. but I wont know unless I try it.
_________________ aka: Steve Mac 78- 21' Tahiti Super Cruiser- 460 w/ Panther Jet
Joined: May 7th, 2009, 10:54 am Posts: 1116 Location: North Highlands, CA
A little more info for the record. To quote the E-Mail I received from Panther Today:
"Try measuring the exit section first. You must have calipers or something very accurate. There are many different size Exit sections for different horsepowers. Compare the dimensions to your Non-cavitating stater. Also take a 3\8 drill bit and make sure the vent holes are open.
If this does not help let us know."
Interesting! First off this bit- There are many different size Exit sections for different horsepowers. I was not aware of MANY different size exit housings for different power levels!
Secondly- Also take a 3\8 drill bit and make sure the vent holes are open. My Stater Vent holes are only drilled 13/64" (just bigger then 3/16") on both exit housings. OK, off to find where my digi brake drum caliper is hiding.
_________________ aka: Steve Mac 78- 21' Tahiti Super Cruiser- 460 w/ Panther Jet
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum